What does she actually know about him vs. imagine?
6 min read
Here's the brutal truth: she knows almost nothing real about him, but her imagination has filled in all the blanks with perfection. What she 'knows' is likely limited to his best moments, his public persona, and carefully curated interactions. What she imagines is a fantasy man who doesn't exist - someone without morning breath, financial stress, bad days, or human flaws. This isn't about you being inadequate. It's about the psychological phenomenon of idealization, where limited information gets filled with projected perfection. She's comparing your full reality - including your worst moments, stress, and humanity - against her fantasy of someone she's never truly known in real life.
The Full Picture
Let's get specific about what's really happening here. Your wife has constructed an elaborate fantasy around this other man based on fragments of information and massive amounts of projection.
What she actually knows is probably limited to: - How he presents himself publicly - Conversations during 'best behavior' moments - His achievements or successes (without the struggle behind them) - His appearance when he's trying to look good - Maybe some shared interests or values
What she's imagining fills in everything else: - How he'd handle stress (spoiler: perfectly) - What he's like when he's sick, tired, or frustrated - How he'd respond to real relationship challenges - His financial habits, personal hygiene, family dynamics - How he'd treat her after the novelty wore off
This is fantasy versus reality comparison - and it's completely unfair. She's comparing your full human experience (including your bad days, stress responses, and real-life pressures) against her idealized version of someone she's never lived with, never seen during crisis, never experienced in the mundane realities of daily life.
The psychological term for this is idealization - and it's incredibly common in emotional affairs. The 'other man' becomes a blank canvas where she projects everything she feels is missing, without any of the reality checks that come with actual intimate knowledge of a person.
Here's what makes this particularly dangerous: the less she actually knows about him, the more perfect he can seem in her imagination.
What's Really Happening
From a clinical perspective, we're witnessing a classic case of projection and idealization that occurs when someone is emotionally dissatisfied in their primary relationship.
The brain literally fills in missing information with idealized content. When your wife has limited real data about this other man, her mind unconsciously projects her unmet needs and desires onto him. This creates what we call a 'fantasy bond' - an emotional //blog.bobgerace.com/shame-script-interruption-marriage-reset-sexual-intimacy/:connection to someone who doesn't actually exist.
What's particularly insidious is the comparison trap this creates. She's essentially comparing two different categories: your full human reality versus her projected fantasy. It's like comparing a real photograph to a heavily filtered, airbrushed image.
The psychology behind this includes: - Confirmation bias: She notices only information that supports her fantasy - Projection: She assigns him qualities he may not possess - Idealization: She minimizes or ignores any potential flaws - Grass-is-greener syndrome: Focused on what seems missing rather than what's present
This isn't about you being deficient. This is about human psychology under stress. The solution isn't to compete with a fantasy - it's to help her recognize the difference between reality and projection, while simultaneously addressing the underlying needs that made the fantasy appealing in the first place.
Recovery requires bringing conscious awareness to this unconscious process.
What Scripture Says
Scripture speaks directly to the dangers of fantasy, comparison, and the importance of truth in relationships.
On the danger of imagination versus reality: *"The heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure. Who can understand it?"* (Jeremiah 17:9). Our hearts can deceive us into believing fantasies feel more real than truth.
On comparison and coveting: *"You shall not covet your neighbor's house, your neighbor's wife, or his male servant, or his female servant, or his ox, or his donkey, or anything that belongs to your neighbor"* (Exodus 20:17). This includes coveting an idealized version of someone else's life or character.
On focusing on truth: *"Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable—if anything is excellent or praiseworthy—think about such things"* (Philippians 4:8). Fantasy relationships rarely meet these biblical standards.
On the importance of commitment to reality: *"Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it"* (Proverbs 4:23). Guarding our hearts means protecting them from deceptive fantasies.
On love grounded in truth: *"Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth"* (1 Corinthians 13:6). Real love is based on knowing and accepting reality, not fantasy.
God's design for marriage requires truth, commitment, and realistic love - not fantasy-based comparisons that can never be satisfied.
What To Do Right Now
-
1
Document the reality gap - write down what she actually knows versus what she's assuming about this other man
-
2
Stop competing with the fantasy - recognize you can't win against an imaginary perfect person
-
3
Ask direct questions about her 'knowledge' - gently challenge assumptions with reality-based questions
-
4
Focus on addressing her real underlying needs rather than the fantasy symptoms
-
5
Set boundaries around fantasy-feeding behaviors like social media stalking or excessive conversation about him
-
6
Seek professional help to address the psychological patterns driving the idealization process
Related Questions
Ready to Address This Reality Gap?
Don't fight a fantasy alone. Get specific strategies to help your wife distinguish between imagination and reality while rebuilding your marriage on solid ground.
Get Help Now →