She says she'll end it but hasn't
6 min read
When your wife promises to end the affair but continues the relationship, you're dealing with someone who is either unwilling or unable to keep their word in the most important area of your marriage. This pattern reveals that words alone won't solve this crisis - action is required. Empty promises are worse than no promises at all because they give false hope while the betrayal continues. At this point, you need to implement clear boundaries with specific consequences. This isn't about punishment - it's about creating conditions that make continuing the affair more difficult than ending it, while protecting your own emotional and spiritual health during this devastating time.
The Full Picture
You're caught in one of the most painful situations a husband can face. She's acknowledged the affair exists, she's promised to end it, but the relationship continues. This creates a unique kind of torture because you have hope mixed with ongoing betrayal.
Why promises without action happen: - She's emotionally attached to the other man and can't break free - She wants to keep both relationships going - She underestimates your resolve to enforce consequences - She's buying time while deciding between you and him - She's addicted to the affair relationship - She genuinely wants to end it but lacks the strength
The harsh reality is that promises are just words. What matters now is behavior, patterns, and choices. Every day she continues the affair after promising to end it, she's choosing him over you and your marriage.
This situation often persists because there are no real consequences for breaking the promise. She gets to keep the excitement of the affair while maintaining the security and benefits of marriage. You've essentially become her safety net while she explores other options.
The danger of accepting empty promises: - Your boundaries become meaningless - She learns she can manipulate you with words - The affair becomes normalized in your relationship - Your self-respect erodes as you accept less than you deserve - You enable the very behavior that's destroying your marriage
This is not the time for more talking, more promises, or more chances. This is the time for clear boundaries backed by real consequences.
What's Really Happening
From a clinical perspective, we're observing what I call 'commitment ambivalence' - your wife is simultaneously attached to two relationships and cannot or will not choose. The neurochemistry of affairs creates powerful emotional bonds that can feel impossible to break, even when someone intellectually knows they should.
The pattern of promising to end it but not following through indicates several possible dynamics: she may be experiencing what we call 'intermittent reinforcement' from the affair partner, which creates an addictive cycle. Or she may be in a state of 'approach-avoidance conflict' where she's genuinely torn between competing attachments.
Research shows that affairs often involve what psychologists call 'fantasy bonding' - an idealized connection that feels more intense than marital love precisely because it exists outside real-world constraints. Breaking this bond requires more than willpower; it requires eliminating contact and replacing the neurochemical reward system.
Your role as the betrayed spouse is not to manage her recovery from the affair - that's her responsibility. Your role is to create clear boundaries that protect your emotional wellbeing and force her to make a definitive choice. Without consequences, there's no motivation for her to endure the emotional pain of ending the affair.
The therapeutic principle here is that change occurs when the pain of staying the same exceeds the pain of changing. Right now, continuing the affair while staying married is her least painful option.
What Scripture Says
Scripture is clear about the importance of keeping our word and the necessity of consequences when promises are broken. Jesus taught us that our 'yes' should mean yes and our 'no' should mean no (Matthew 5:37). When someone repeatedly breaks their word in marriage, biblical wisdom calls for a measured response.
Matthew 18:15-17 outlines the process for addressing sin: 'If your brother or sister sins, go and point out their fault, just between the two of you. If they listen to you, you have won them over. But if they will not listen, take one or two others along... If they still refuse to listen, tell it to the church; and if they refuse to listen even to the church, treat them as you would a pagan or a tax collector.' This principle applies to marriage - escalating consequences when repentance doesn't lead to change.
Galatians 6:7 reminds us that 'God cannot be mocked. A man reaps what he sows.' Allowing someone to continue destructive behavior without consequences actually prevents them from experiencing the natural results of their choices, which God designed to lead us toward repentance and change.
Proverbs 27:5-6 teaches that 'Better is open rebuke than hidden love. Wounds from a friend can be trusted, but an enemy multiplies kisses.' Sometimes the most loving thing you can do is create painful consequences that force someone to face the reality of their choices.
1 Corinthians 5:11-13 shows us that even in Christian community, there are times when we must separate from those engaged in ongoing sin. This isn't about condemnation - it's about creating conditions that promote repentance and restoration.
What To Do Right Now
-
1
Set a clear, specific deadline: 'The affair ends completely by [specific date] or I will [specific consequence]'
-
2
Define what 'ending it' means: no contact, blocked numbers, changed jobs if necessary, complete transparency
-
3
Prepare your consequences in advance: separation, financial separation, involving family, or filing for divorce
-
4
Document everything: save evidence of continued contact, broken promises, and your clear communications
-
5
Build your support network: inform trusted friends, family, or counselors who will hold you accountable to follow through
-
6
Follow through immediately when the deadline passes - no extensions, no negotiations, no second chances at this stage
Related Questions
Stop Accepting Empty Promises
You deserve better than broken promises and continued betrayal. Let's create a plan with real boundaries and consequences that protect your marriage and your dignity.
Get Help Now →