She says she needs time to decide

6 min read

Marriage coaching advice for men when wife says she needs time to choose between husband and affair partner

When your wife says she needs time to decide between you and another man, she's essentially asking for permission to continue her affair while keeping you as backup. This is unacceptable and requires immediate boundaries. You cannot allow yourself to be part of a competition for your own wife's affections. The harsh reality is that asking for time to decide is often a way to avoid making the difficult choice to end the affair. During this 'decision time,' the emotional and physical connection with the other man typically continues or even deepens. You must establish clear consequences and timelines rather than accepting an indefinite period of uncertainty that damages you and your marriage further.

The Full Picture

This isn't really about needing time - it's about avoiding consequences.

When a wife says she needs time to decide, she's revealing several troubling realities about where your marriage stands. First, she's admitting that another man has become a viable alternative to you in her mind. Second, she's asking you to wait patiently while she continues to invest emotionally (and possibly physically) in someone else. Third, she's avoiding the immediate consequences that should naturally follow the discovery of infidelity.

The request for time often comes after the affair has been discovered or confronted. Instead of immediately choosing her marriage and ending all contact with the other man, she wants to keep both options open. This creates an impossible situation where you're expected to compete for your own wife while she maintains her relationship with another man.

What's really happening during this 'time to decide': - She continues contact with the other man, often justifying it as 'figuring things out' - The affair relationship typically intensifies because of the heightened drama and emotion - You experience ongoing trauma and uncertainty while trying to 'win her back' - Your marriage relationship becomes increasingly damaged by the continued betrayal - She avoids facing the full weight of her choices and their consequences

The competition dynamic is toxic and unsustainable. Marriage isn't a contest where two men compete for a woman's affections. It's a covenant relationship that requires exclusive commitment. By accepting the 'time to decide' framework, you're inadvertently agreeing to a fundamentally wrong premise about how marriage works.

This situation often paralyzes husbands who fear that setting boundaries or ultimatums will push their wives toward the other man. However, the opposite is usually true - clear boundaries and consequences often create the clarity needed for someone to make the right choice.

What's Really Happening

From a psychological perspective, the request for 'time to decide' reflects several concerning dynamics. The unfaithful spouse is experiencing what we call 'decision paralysis' - not because both options are equally valid, but because she's avoiding the emotional pain of fully confronting her choices.

The affair relationship exists in what I call 'fantasy space' - it's not burdened by daily responsibilities, financial stress, or the normal challenges of committed partnership. Meanwhile, the marriage carries all the weight of real life. This creates an unfair comparison that becomes more skewed the longer the affair continues.

Neurologically, the affair creates powerful chemical bonds through dopamine and norepinephrine - the same chemicals involved in addiction. The 'high' of the affair relationship makes normal marital love feel mundane by comparison. Time doesn't heal this chemical bond; distance and no contact do.

The husband's willingness to wait often reinforces the wife's sense that he'll always be there, reducing the urgency to choose the marriage. This creates what psychologists call 'intermittent reinforcement' - the most powerful way to maintain someone's behavior. She gets the excitement of the affair plus the security of knowing her husband is waiting.

Healthy decision-making requires clear consequences and boundaries. When we shield people from the natural results of their choices, we actually impair their ability to make good decisions. The loving thing is often to create the clarity that comes from real consequences, not to enable continued destructive behavior.

What Scripture Says

Scripture is clear that marriage requires exclusive commitment and that infidelity has serious consequences that must be addressed directly.

Marriage is exclusive and decisive: *'Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh'* (Matthew 19:5). The biblical vision of marriage doesn't include a 'trial period' to decide between spouses and lovers. The commitment is clear and total.

Divided loyalty destroys: *'No one can serve two masters, for either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other'* (Matthew 6:24). This principle applies directly to marriage - a wife cannot serve both her husband and her lover. The attempt to do so inevitably damages both relationships and her own integrity.

Love requires decisive action: *'And if it is evil in your eyes to serve the Lord, choose this day whom you will serve'* (Joshua 24:15). Joshua didn't give Israel indefinite time to decide about their loyalty to God. Sometimes love requires immediate, decisive choice. A husband can lovingly but firmly require his wife to choose immediately rather than enabling continued betrayal.

Truth demands clarity: *'Let what you say be simply "Yes" or "No"; anything more than this comes from evil'* (Matthew 5:37). The request for endless time to decide often comes from wanting to avoid the clear 'yes' or 'no' that the situation demands.

Consequences teach righteousness: *'For the moment all discipline seems painful rather than pleasant, but later it yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness'* (Hebrews 12:11). Setting clear boundaries and consequences isn't cruel - it's loving discipline that can lead to restoration.

Restoration requires repentance: *'If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone'* (Matthew 18:15). Biblical restoration doesn't begin with extended deliberation periods but with acknowledging wrong and taking immediate corrective action.

What To Do Right Now

  1. 1

    Set a clear, short timeline (48-72 hours maximum) for her to choose the marriage and end all contact with the other man

  2. 2

    Refuse to participate in any 'comparison' discussions or compete for your wife's affections

  3. 3

    Remove yourself as the backup option by clearly stating the consequences if she doesn't choose the marriage immediately

  4. 4

    Consult with a lawyer to understand your legal options and protect your interests

  5. 5

    Build your support network - don't go through this alone or in secret

  6. 6

    Focus on your own healing and strength rather than trying to convince her to choose you

Related Questions

Don't Navigate This Crisis Alone

This situation requires immediate, strategic action. I'll help you set the right boundaries and consequences to protect yourself and give your marriage the best chance.

Get Help Now →